Friday, June 5, 2015

Character Traits: Poor Judgment

Last time I discussed characters who possessed the notorious trait of being “Stubborn” and what that might look like. Stubbornness is an interesting trait because it’s very accessible and common among people, and many quickly apply it to their new characters, at least in name. But there are lots of character traits that are both accessible and common, and yet you tend to see characters who are ‘Stubborn’ far more often than you see a character whose author will willingly ascribe them to have ‘Poor Judgment’. I think there is a convincing reason why that is, though.

As I mentioned previously, stubbornness is very easily a flaw that is not a flaw. It gives the character, at face value, an appearance of humanity, but it is often not written convincingly at all. Most stubborn characters are chronically correct, and their stubbornness usually helps the plot or character more than it hinders it. I don’t bring this up simply for the sake of being repetitive, however; rather, I want to contrast it with a different trait, one that is much harder to escape from humiliation with. Characters who possess notably poor judgment are hard to come by, and yet people with notably poor judgment seem a dime a dozen. Feel like we’re missing something here?

Thursday, May 7, 2015

Hypothetical Character Flaws

Here’s a concept for you: a hypothetically flawed character. This character, on the surface, is not a perfect person because of their flaws, but in practice it remains to be seen how truly flawed they actually are. I am talking, of course, of “practice” in the context of roleplay, here, but you could make a similar argument for fictional narratives as a whole.

In my head, this how I’m thinking about it. If a character’s ‘goodness’ is the sum of their good traits (Strengths) minus their bad traits (Flaws), you get a character who lands somewhere in the realm of “Good” (More Strengths than Flaws), “Neutral” (Strengths and Flaws roughly equal), or “Bad” (Flaws outweigh the Strengths). Some people might refer to “Bad” as “Evil” if you want to use the DnD scale, but you see where I’m going with this. So let me mess with that formula a little bit.

Sunday, April 19, 2015

Theatrics Ruin Writing


A gust whistled through a broken window, the only sound in the abandoned flat besides the thrumming of the storm outside. Dragging his feet, defeated, a lone man limped across the floor, looking to his left and right frantically while wiping his bloody nose between haggard breaths. Punctuating the silence, a flash of lightning followed by an immediate peal of thunder shook the building, and the man yelped. He tried to spin on one foot, but his ruined leg was claimed his balance, and he collapsed in a tumble, biting off a curse in the process.

As if from nowhere, a figure emerged in front him, stepping out of the shadows, and then he really screamed. Whatever noise came out of his mouth, though, was swallowed by another peal of thunder, and the cracked window howled all the louder. A cloaked figure seemed to tower in front of him and, despite the obscured face, he recognized him.

“Y-you! You’re the guy who killed my brother. P-please, we didn’t mean—” His fumbling voice broke off into a low whine, though, as the figure raised handgun, brandishing death itself as it pulled its hood back.

“Tell him I said hello, yeah?” the voice responded, and he blinked in-spite of his own terror. It was a woman? His mouth tried to form confused words, but a gunshot chorused with the thundering storm outside, and the night grew darker.

…

…Not doing it for you? Yeah. Let’s talk about it.

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Character Traits: Stubborn

Cooking up a character is relatively easy, not entirely dissimilar from cooking up a meal. Doing it well is another matter entirely. Too little spice and the food dries out—too much and it smolders in your mouth. Some flavors and textures complement each other, and others do not. Some are niche and some are staples. 

Writing a good character is hard enough as it is. It becomes harder, though, when people mix up the components into a hodge-podge and expect it to work on its own. Some people have an iron gut for characters—anything will do—but a balanced and believable character is hard to come by, and, when you do, it’s even harder to go back. Character traits are essential for breathing life into your character, but it’s important to know what you’re using, before you mix it into the bowl. I'd love to talk about a lot of them, but one at a time will do for now.

Wednesday, October 29, 2014

Standards of Roleplay

  1. Believable characters make for more interesting roleplay, even in a fantastical setting.

  2. A strong character is flawed on multiple levels. A true flaw is not a blessing in disguise and should pervasively hinder the character throughout the roleplay.

  3. A character is made unique, individual, and interesting by how they interact with the world and by the choices they make. Power, talent, and ability are secondary at best.

  4. Limited freedom is a powerful source for creativity. Restrictive roles in the setting do not hinder a character or story—they enhance them.

  5. The knowledge, emotions, and values of a writer are separate and different from that writer’s character. This distinction must never be compromised or confused.

  6. An excellent roleplayer must be both a strong writer and a talented storyteller. One without the other holds very little value.

  7. Roleplay is, by definition, social. The best roleplayers pay meticulous attention to the other writer and rely on their responses to craft their own.

  8. The most valuable roleplaying partner is an active one; joining a roleplay is a commitment never to be broken lightly.

  9. Roleplay is active, dynamic, and character driven. A writer’s plan is useful but held loosely.

  10. Roleplay is a chance to experience spontaneous interaction in a unique setting. Using it to fulfil a craving or escapist desire is a poor basis for writing and will easily undermine any item on this list. 

(Certain items from this list, while rewritten, draw heavily from another list masterfully written by a good friend of mine named Genavie. Her original work can be found: here) 


Sunday, October 5, 2014

The Struggle: Strengths and Weaknesses


Every interesting character has their strengths and their weaknesses; the first enables them to compete in the storyline, and the second makes it difficult for them to succeed. Whether it’s their raw intelligence coupled with overweening pride, incredible strength paired against low wits, or tact and guile against callous character, each individual struggles and fights against things. These characteristics are, importantly, not external but rather internal, byproducts of the individual’s own character and not the events around them, though both will motivate the story. This balance between strength and weakness is of utmost importance to develop interesting, character-driven stories in all fiction, but it’s incredibly difficult to do well. Just the few examples I listed seem fairly trite, but executed properly they form the foundations for some of the most interesting characters you and I know. So how do they do it? Let’s look at it from a roleplaying perspective.

Thursday, September 4, 2014

Write Real Characters, Not Rational Ones


One of the greatest blessings and curses of roleplaying is that every writer has an audience. Whether it’s posting the character sheet or responding to the roleplaying thread the character is in, each person expects what they’ve written to be read. On the one hand, this is great because it gives writers a real, living experience for their creations to live in. But on the other hand, this also means that even the people who really aren’t writers, at their cores, can still play creative fiction on their unsuspecting victims.

In practice, what you end up getting is a pretty steady demographic with roleplaying. Every roleplayer I’ve met has fancied themselves a fairly intelligent, rational person in their own minds. That may very well be the case, and there’s nothing particularly wrong with it, but it does have some serious implications for the sorts of characters you run into in your adventures. As we have already long since established, people are inherently drawn (usually unhelpfully) to write portions of themselves into characters. You should tread lightly.